Evaluating the material circularity indicator (MCI) in business models as a circular design tool for sustainable biocomposite product development
Paudel, Mana Hari (2026)
Diplomityö
Paudel, Mana Hari
2026
School of Energy Systems, Konetekniikka
Julkaisun pysyvä osoite on
https://urn.fi/URN:NBN:fi-fe20260930130088
https://urn.fi/URN:NBN:fi-fe20260930130088
Tiivistelmä
The circular economy addresses the environmental and resource challenges of linear production. Companies use quantitative indicators to guide circularity decisions, such as the Material Circularity Indicator (MCI), developed by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation and Granta Design, which uses a mass-flow formulation. However, its suitability for biocomposites remains unclear. This thesis evaluates MCI as a decision-support tool for a biocomposite product developed by the case company. Three scenarios are assessed using the MCI Whole Product approach: a conventional PVC baseline, a biocomposite scenario with 100% recycled feedstock, and a scenario combining 80% recycled and 20% reused material. A sensitivity analysis examines how recycled content affects the MCI score.
Biocomposite scenarios achieve higher MCI scores than the baseline, driven mainly by feedstock composition rather than end-of-life recovery, as collection rates remain constant across scenarios. The analysis identifies the recycled content threshold for high-circularity classification. A workshop with the case company confirmed that MCI outputs were interpretable and credible, and that input data were largely accessible through existing EPD documentation. Results confirmed existing intuitions, and cost remained the dominant decision factor, positioning MCI as a validation tool rather than a recovery tool. MCI’s inability to capture quality degradation, environmental trade-offs, and systemic end-of-life uncertainties limits its standalone value and combining it with complementary indicators is recommended.
Biocomposite scenarios achieve higher MCI scores than the baseline, driven mainly by feedstock composition rather than end-of-life recovery, as collection rates remain constant across scenarios. The analysis identifies the recycled content threshold for high-circularity classification. A workshop with the case company confirmed that MCI outputs were interpretable and credible, and that input data were largely accessible through existing EPD documentation. Results confirmed existing intuitions, and cost remained the dominant decision factor, positioning MCI as a validation tool rather than a recovery tool. MCI’s inability to capture quality degradation, environmental trade-offs, and systemic end-of-life uncertainties limits its standalone value and combining it with complementary indicators is recommended.
Kokoelmat
Samankaltainen aineisto
Näytetään aineisto, joilla on samankaltaisia nimekkeitä, tekijöitä tai asiasanoja.
-
Circular business model innovation – a process framework and a tool towards more circular economy
Talukder, Masudul Haque (2017)Circular economy can play a vital role to solve the material scarcity, environmental and social problems but it needs new business models. However, the existing methods for business model innovation are not competent in ... -
Circular business models for increasing critical raw materials circularity in urban environment : case e-bikes
Kaivonen, Timo (2024)Having secured access to Critical Raw Materials is extremely important to the economy and security of Europe since those materials are needed in a variety of goods and key technologies which are used every day. To address ... -
The opportunities and challenges for circular business in the lithium-ion battery value chain
Torkkeli, Laura (2022)The UNFCCC’s Paris Agreement targets on climate change and the aim to reduce emissions on the energy intensive sectors, transportation, and energy production, creates enormous pressure to electrify mobility and to expand ...



